Covergirl Professional Remarkable Washable Waterproof Mascara (very black)

Pros:
Minimal Flaking
Does not clump
Can look natural or dramatic (Buildable)
Does not irritate eyes
Volumizing + Lengthening
Brush good size and shape for application
Water resistant
Easily removed (especially compared to regular waterproof formulas) 

Cons:
Takes a few coats to get adequate volume
Not truly waterproof
Residual "stickiness" may be present throughout the day (eyelashes sticking together)

I am looking forward to using this mascara for the next week to truly test its durability on a regular basis. I am extremely excited about it! I had less flaking with this mascara than any of the other ones I have tried recently, even after laying several coats on my lashes. I also love that the mascara is easy to remove and that I don't feel like I am removing all of my lashes with it. I would recommend giving this product a try!

Product Review: L'oreal Voluminous Carbon Black

                                      

Pros:
Natural Look or Dramatic Look achievable
Buildable
Non-Irritating
Doesn't Clump
Lasts throughout the day
Holds a curl
Separates lashes

Cons:
Moderate Flaking

All in all this is a very good product. I love the way it looks when it's applied, it adds drama without creating fake clumped eyelashes. It very much accentuates the natural lashes which I think looks great on everyone. I wish that I didn't have as many problems with this product flaking. This may or may not be a problem for you depending on your skin type and what other eye makeup you wear. I would recommend giving this product a try!